The popular defender cleaned up on the night and was also named the Supporters' Player of the Year.
Speaking after the event, Carl said: "It was obviously nice to receive personal recognition – that's always nice. But I'd happily swap all of these for the Play-Off final trophy.
"Promotion is what it's all about and that's what I came here for – I wanted to be part of a successful team."
And Terry Hall was a worthy winner of the Grimsby Town Supporter of the Year. Terry, who runs the Mariners Travel club, received several nominations for the award.
And Jack Mackreth's fantastic left-foot strike against Gateshead (below) was chosen as the Goal of the Season by the GTFC camera crew.